Why Is Theistic Evolution a Lie?

This thought occurred to me when I read I John 2:21:

 I have not written to you because you do not know the truth, but because you do know it, and because no lie is of the truth. (NASB)

 John says you can’t mix the truth with a lie and still have truth. When you mix truth with a lie you don’t get a mixture of truth and falsehood; you lose the truth entirely and end up with nothing other than a lie.

 Get the Picture

 Here is a physical analogy to picture in your mind. Suppose you have a gallon of pure, reverse osmosis filtered drinking water, and another gallon of pond water that contains mud, scum and loads of bacteria. If you pour the pure drinking water and the pond water into a container what do you have, a mixture of pure and impure water? Of course not. You have two gallons of impure water that is unfit to drink. When you combined the pure water with the pond water it lost its purity. Likewise, when you combine truth with a lie you lose the truth entirely and have only a lie left.

 Theistic Evolution

 This principle could be applied to many concepts; but let’s take theistic evolution as an example. It is an attempt to combine the Bible’s teaching about creation with Darwinian evolution. I think it is fair to say that Darwinian evolution is at its core an attempt to explain the existence of life on this planet in purely naturalistic terms without the need for a Creator. In other words life arose and developed by random processes without any aid or intervention from a power or intelligence outside the system. I doubt if Richard Dawkins or any other Darwinian evolutionist would argue with that statement.

 Theistic evolutionists have tried to interpret the Genesis account of creation to make it compatible with Darwinian evolution. They have tried the “gap theory”and the “day-age theory”. Because of inherent problems in those theories they have resorted to non-literal interpretation methods, such as spiritualizing and allegory. The end result of these ill conceived methods is to hide the simple truth explicitly taught in Genesis: that God spoke the universe and all life into existence in a special act of creation in six literal days.

 Theistic evolution is bad theology and Darwinian evolution is bad science. I intend to write many blogs to support that statement, but I want you to know up front where I am coming from. When you try to mix Biblical creationism with Darwinian evolution you do not get a half-truth, or a mixture of truth and error. When you mix truth with a lie you end up with a lie. Period.

John Otis has written a timeless critique of theistic evolution that is easy to read and understand. Use this link to access Theistic Evolution: a Sinful Compromise.

 J. Ray Smith, President, Fair Havens Publications, www.fairhavensmedia.com/blog

Your Invitation to Community

The support of a Christian community is crucial to face a difficult future. Of course, you want to be active in a local Bible-teaching church. Here are two other Christian communities that can benefit you.

There is a growing community of over 80,000 Christians who share the burden of health care costs. The Smith family have been members of this community for many years, and have saved literally thousands of dollars as a result. When one of us went to the emergency room and ran up a $5,000 bill, the community shared the cost with us. It worked!

Here are some of the benefits when you join:

  • Lower Costs Families average around $300 a month, and seniors use an inexpensive plan to supplement Medicare.
  • Choice of Doctor Select your doctor from PHCS, America’s largest network of health providers.
  • Exemption from The Affordable Care Act You will not be required to buy insurance or face penalties.
  • Respect for Your Christian Convictions You never have to pay for prescriptions or procedures that break God’s heart.

 If you are interested in these benefits and more that were not described, then use this button:

 FYI Fair Havens Publications has an affiliate relationship with the above organization. We neither ask for nor accept donations, but when you join the health care Christian community through our link you are helping Fair Havens continue to provide the helpful free articles on this web site and offer quality Christian publications for sale through our other media outlets.

The Barnabas Community

Here is another way to receive support from other Christians. Become a part of the “Barnabas Community” by subscribing to our free monthly newsletter. Barnabas was an evangelist who encouraged and aided both Paul and Mark in their ministries. His name means “Son of Prophecy”. The purpose of the newsletter is to encourage you to face the future and share your faith with confidence. We invite members to share needs or inspiring experiences.

Get More Info

Comment and Share

What do you think about theistic evolution? Would you take a moment to enter the discussion and share a comment? Please see our Comment Policy below.

Also, it would be a great help to this new blog if you would use the tool bar on your left to share it with your friends and give it a “like” in social media.


Permission is granted to post this article on your web site or reproduce it for a teaching ministry provided it is used in its entirety with no editing or omissions, and if the author’s tag line is included with the company name and web address or link if used on a web site. This article may not be used for commercial purposes without additional permission from Fair Havens Publications. Please see “Permission” in the tool bar above.

Comment Policy

Your comments are welcome, even if you do not agree with us. We require that you limit them to the subject of the blog, show respect and civility, and refrain from abusive or inappropriate language. We reserve the right to remove comments at our sole discretion.


Fair Havens Publications is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.